1.16.2013

letter, kt tobin to chris marx


KT Tobin (former Vice President, New Paltz School Board) to Chris Marx Highway Superintendant


I have some questions about the T/V New Paltz consolidation study HR and Finance reports. It is my understanding that as elected Town of New Paltz Highway Superintendent you participated in and contributed to these committees and made recommendations that were included in their final reports.

A. In the HR report, from page 4, section I, item D:

  1. What was the basis for this statement? "Based on input from department heads, council persons  and others the committee has been advised that as many as 13 full time positions can be eliminated with many of these positions coming from buildings and grounds."
  2. How many positions did you recommend be eliminated from the town highway department?
  3. Please provide both the workload and safety analysis that provided the basis for making this recommendation to reduce your staff
  4. Please provide your assessment of the potential impacts on service delivery, e.g. how much longer it will take to plow all the roads in a typical snow storm
  5. Please provide your assessment of the impact of these recommendations on worker morale and fair collective bargaining practices.
  6. Please provide the timeline that you constructed in order to implement the proposed reduction in staffing

B. In the HR report, from page 9, section III, item 2 reads, "Employee head count reductions should coincide with retirement to the extent possible" (italics added).

  1. Did you recommend this strategy?
  2. Which positions from your answer above (1b) did you recommend be reduced via retirement?
  3. Which positions did you foresee reducing via other means and what were those means?

C.  In the HR report, from page 9, section III, item 3 recommends transitioning to a part-time staff to reduce health care and retirement costs

  1. Did you recommend this strategy?
  2. How many positions did you recommend be transitioned to part-time positions?
  3. Which positions from your answer above (1b) did you recommend be transitioned to part-time via retirement of full-time workers?
  4. Which positions did you foresee transitioning to part-time via other means and what were those means?
  5. Please provide both the workload and safety implications for this type of staffing more reliant on a part-time workforce.
  6. Please provide your assessment of the potential impact on service delivery based on staffing more reliant more part-time workers, e.g. how much longer it will take to plow all the roads in a typical snow storm
  7. Please provide your assessment of the impact of these recommendations on worker morale and fair collective bargaining practices.
  8. Please provide the timeline that you constructed to implement the proposed transition in staffing

D. From the Finance report data on public works departments:

  • $2,699,936 Total town + village budget
  • $2,179,859 Merged budget
  • $ 520,077 Savings

  1. How was the savings of $520,777 derived? Please provide an itemized list with associated savings including positions, materials, etc.
  2. Please provide both the workload and safety analysis behind your recommendations included in the $520,777 reduction.
  3. Please provide your assessment of impact on service delivery that will result from your recommendations, e.g. how much longer it will take to plow all the roads in a typical snow storm.
  4. Please provide the timeline that you constructed to implement the proposed savings.

Thank you for serving New Paltz.

I look forward to your prompt response.

letter to the editor from steve greenfield


A very interesting thing about the turnout for public comment at the joint Town-Village meeting held last Thursday to consider text for a consolidation referendum: a whole bunch of people with many years of successful local government budgeting experience and relevant professional credentials came down to critique the financial report at the heart of the matter. These included people favoring consolidation, people opposing it, and people who are neutral, and were hoping clear data would help them make up their minds -- in other words, three completely different perspectives -- yet all of them were issuing the exact same critique -- the financial report is an epic fail. And so it is.

Pro-consolidation people in particular must consider the implications of this. People already in the "no" column are obviously going to stay there. People in the "not sure yet" column have nothing to move them towards "yes," and much in the combativeness of the defense of the document by its purveyors to confirm suspicions that it is politicized to the point of being potentially fraudulent. And for those of us leaning towards "yes," the report as it now stands pretty much guarantees that should the matter be hastily put to a referendum, it will not only fail to garner passage, but in so doing, will send it to the "dead issue" pile for at least another generation, if not forever.

Town Supervisor Susan Zimet's contention that the matter must be rushed to the ballot booths before May, lest the composition of the Village Board change to one less inclined to put the matter to referendum at all, is the exact wrong approach for consolidation advocates to take. Is there a risk that new Village trustees may be elected in May who will not vote to go to referendum? Sure. And if most Villagers are anti-consolidation, that's a legitimate way for them to express that, saving the expense and divisiveness of the referendum process. But they might not. And even if they do, there's another Village election in two years. Weigh that against the risk of putting it to the public now, with no supporting data; with a mountain of data that is demonstrably false; with the risks completely ignored; and with prominent pro-consolidation residents refusing to support the vote due to bad information. Because in that scenario, it's the consolidation itself that fails, not the process of getting it to the voters, and when that happens, it's over for good.

If New Paltz citizens, no matter what their initial position on this matter may be, are to have the fair debate to which they are entitled on a matter of such historic import, and if pro-consolidation citizens in particular are to have a reasonable chance at their goal, the pause button has to be hit right now. Everyone please contact your Town and Village Board members, and ask that the process be delayed for at least as long as it may take to unpack what went wrong with the financial report, and to reassemble it with useful, plainly verifiable data.

1.15.2013

2013-1-15 joint town/village board meeting, with commentary

2013-1-15 Joint Board Meeting


Jeff Logan, Town Councilman
On [the] Youtube video go to 2:35:00 ..... Dave [Lent] says he doesn't know where [the] savings came from '...[Village Superintendant of Public Works] Bleu [Terwilliger] and [Town Highway Superintendant] Chris [Marx] came up with those savings...' I am confused.



Mike Russo, Town resident
After saying her piece about the videos, Susan at 2h40m then explains the Fiscal Committee methodology in analyzing 2011 figures, just as described on page 1 of the Report. Yet Sally's subsequent explanation of the DPW/Highway savings makes reference to 2012 costs and 2013 budget lines as components of the $520,077 calculation. So it sounds like there is inconsistency in the committee's methodology. In the 30 minutes I watched of the 12/3/2012 FC meeting at around 21m, there's discussion around questions of methodology, and even a vague passing mention of the Building and Grounds costs."




Mike Russo, Town resident
To follow [up] on Jeff Logan's reference to the video, right after Dave Lent's comments at 2h35m-2h38m, and Jeff's questions in response, [Deputy Mayor] Sally [Rhoads] states that the figures were compiled by [Town Supervisor] Susan [Zimet], Sally, Bleu and Chris. Then Susan makes the point that every discussion was videoed, implying that we can find all the answers if we watch the videos. So maybe someone who attended the meetings could help us out a little in pointing out the date and committee meeting when the DPW/Highway lines were discussed. I'd hate to have to watch all the videos, only to find out that Bleu was correct in recalling that the one meeting he participated in was not videoed. To expect the public to have to pour through hours of videos is much like saying if you desperately need a needle, there's one in that haystack."



Mike Russo, Town resident
I just drafted a letter summing up all the above and more, but since the next Joint Meeting of the Town and Village is tomorrow [1/15/13], when Q&A takes place, much of what I wrote may already be discussed. I'm wondering if some of the supporting documents to the savings claims will be made available at tomorrow's meeting:
  1. The single largest cost savings line in the Expenditures spreadsheet is comprised from a collection of DPW and Highway item lines. The total savings is stated as $520,077. This figure seems unrealistically high for savings realized by consolidation, since regardless of whether we have one or two governments, we still have the same number of roads to be plowed and repaired, and the same number of vehicles, more or less, to be maintained. Consolidating to one garage will save a limited amount of money. So how will this cost savings be realized?  Note: I would like to ask follow-up questions in person in regard to this question.
  2. Regarding Line items A3120.1&2&4, why is a $300,000 reduction in police expenditures being counted as consolidation savings when the annotation states "reduced due extenuating circumstances in 2011, no longer anticipate"? That brief note seems to imply that the $300,000 reduction has been already taken place, and has nothing to do with whether or not consolidation takes place. Please clarify.
  3. The Fiscal Committee report contains a sentence that reads "Please note: The consolidated budget presented reflects personnel adjustments already made in the 2013 adopted Town Budget, and therefore, there are minimal employee impacts (except for elected personnel)." This statement suggests to me that labor savings that has already been initiated in the Town per its 2013 Budget is being presented erroneously in the report as savings that would be obtained by means of consolidation. Those 2013 personnel adjustments should show up as a correction line in the cost analysis and not be included in the tally for savings due to consolidation, yet I see no such correction. This leads me to believe that those personnel adjustments that are already in place and unrelated to consolidation, are nevertheless being included as savings in the various labor lines and the labor-related lines, such as A9010.8, A9030.8, A9040.8, A9060.8. Please clarify.
  4. Line item A1420.4 Law expenditures in 2011 for the village and town were about $58,997 and $115,484 respectively, so how could consolidation result in a reduction of these costs to $95,000, a much lower amount than the Town’s costs alone? On what possible basis relating to consolidation, would legal costs drop by 45%?
  5. Line item A1440.4 Engineer is being cut from $137,071 in combined 2011 expenditures to $50,000. Such a decrease seems unrealistic. Furthermore, since the village had less than $2,000 in 2011 costs, why would this $86,971 in cost reduction be counted as savings due to consolidation.
  6. The consolidation of Treasurer, Personnel/Payroll and Bookkeeping/Budget (A1325.1, A1340.1, A1430.1) is shown as yielding a 25% savings. That seems highly optimistic. Since this line is primarily labor and related, what are the specifics in terms of job roles and costs of the analysis of the combined workloads that determined that 25% of the tasks are duplicative of town and village?
  7. Line item A1680.4 Data Processing shows consolidation savings estimated at $25,650, a 33% reduction. While one would expect that consolidation will realize savings in Data Processing costs, the total number of workstations and software user licenses will not decrease; therefore this seems like unrealistically high reduction in costs. What are the specifics in terms of item and dollar costs that would result in a reduction of 33% in costs?
  8. Line item A1650.4 is Town Central Communications Contractual, for which the entire $40,535 of expenditures is in the Savings column because, according to the spreadsheet note, this item is absorbed by consolidation into Line A1680.4 Data Processing. But since Data Processing expenditures is already reduced by 33%, it would seem that expenditures for this Central Communications line item are being completely eliminated. Is this an accurate assumption? What are the individual components of this line’s $40,535 costs? How much of the savings would directly relate to consolidation?




Mike Russo, Town resident
January 17 at 8:52pm




public comments by mike russo


I just drafted a letter summing up all the above and more, but since the next Joint Meeting of the Town and Village is tomorrow [1/15/13], when Q&A takes place, much of what I wrote may already be discussed. I'm wondering if some of the supporting documents to the savings claims will be made available at tomorrow's meeting.
  1. The single largest cost savings line in the Expenditures spreadsheet is comprised from a collection of DPW and Highway item lines. The total savings is stated as $520,077. This figure seems unrealistically high for savings realized by consolidation, since regardless of whether we have one or two governments, we still have the same number of roads to be plowed and repaired, and the same number of vehicles, more or less, to be maintained. Consolidating to one garage will save a limited amount of money. So how will this cost savings be realized?  Note: I would like to ask follow-up questions in person in regard to this question.
  2. Regarding Line items A3120.1&2&4, why is a $300,000 reduction in police expenditures being counted as consolidation savings when the annotation states "reduced due extenuating circumstances in 2011, no longer anticipate"? That brief note seems to imply that the $300,000 reduction has been already taken place, and has nothing to do with whether or not consolidation takes place. Please clarify.
  3. The Fiscal Committee report contains a sentence that reads "Please note: The consolidated budget presented reflects personnel adjustments already made in the 2013 adopted Town Budget, and therefore, there are minimal employee impacts (except for elected personnel)." This statement suggests to me that labor savings that has already been initiated in the Town per its 2013 Budget is being presented erroneously in the report as savings that would be obtained by means of consolidation. Those 2013 personnel adjustments should show up as a correction line in the cost analysis and not be included in the tally for savings due to consolidation, yet I see no such correction. This leads me to believe that those personnel adjustments that are already in place and unrelated to consolidation, are nevertheless being included as savings in the various labor lines and the labor-related lines, such as A9010.8, A9030.8, A9040.8, A9060.8. Please clarify.
  4. Line item A1420.4 Law expenditures in 2011 for the village and town were about $58,997 and $115,484 respectively, so how could consolidation result in a reduction of these costs to $95,000, a much lower amount than the Town’s costs alone? On what possible basis relating to consolidation, would legal costs drop by 45%?
  5. Line item A1440.4 Engineer is being cut from $137,071 in combined 2011 expenditures to $50,000. Such a decrease seems unrealistic. Furthermore, since the village had less than $2,000 in 2011 costs, why would this $86,971 in cost reduction be counted as savings due to consolidation.
  6. The consolidation of Treasurer, Personnel/Payroll and Bookkeeping/Budget (A1325.1, A1340.1, A1430.1) is shown as yielding a 25% savings. That seems highly optimistic. Since this line is primarily labor and related, what are the specifics in terms of job roles and costs of the analysis of the combined workloads that determined that 25% of the tasks are duplicative of town and village?
  7. Line item A1680.4 Data Processing shows consolidation savings estimated at $25,650, a 33% reduction. While one would expect that consolidation will realize savings in Data Processing costs, the total number of workstations and software user licenses will not decrease; therefore this seems like unrealistically high reduction in costs. What are the specifics in terms of item and dollar costs that would result in a reduction of 33% in costs?
  8. Line item A1650.4 is Town Central Communications Contractual, for which the entire $40,535 of expenditures is in the Savings column because, according to the spreadsheet note, this item is absorbed by consolidation into Line A1680.4 Data Processing. But since Data Processing expenditures is already reduced by 33%, it would seem that expenditures for this Central Communications line item are being completely eliminated. Is this an accurate assumption? What are the individual components of this line’s $40,535 costs? How much of the savings would directly relate to consolidation?
  9. This question is to be posed to the members of the Town and Village Boards. Many arguments could be advanced as to why consolidation may be good for our community. But the likely assumption is that for most voters, the tax rates issue is going to be front and center- they will vote for consolidation if there's the promise of significant reduction of taxes. That's why the financial picture of consolidation has to addressed with the upmost of care. Most people are too busy or not comfortable to delve deep in the analysis of double-checking and questioning the figures given to them by public officials, even if they are provided full information. As elected officials, you are charged with the public trust, with the responsibility to present a fair and clear assessment of what savings would be obtained by the consolidation of the Village and Town governments. I must admit that I am surprised and troubled by the many flaws, inaccuracies and obfuscations that appear to be present in the Expenditures spreadsheet and by the stridency of the Fiscal Committee’s report and recommendation made on the
    basis of this problematic analysis. I am further troubled by the sharp contrast of the Fiscal Committee's
    high figure for savings due to consolidation as compared with the 2011 Fairweather study, which on
    pages 23-24 (of version 2.1) suggests that savings due to consolidation is likely to be modest, and
    states "This reiterates the concept that restructuring through consolidation is not an effective means in
    overall reduction of the cost of local government." What will happen, if consolidation is approved and
    then it turns out that the expert consultants, in fact, were right? Therefore, I ask of all Town and Village elected officials: Will you agree to retain a reputable accounting firm to perform a professional grade report on the cost savings analysis using current budgets and cost projections, before scheduling any referendum on the issue of consolidation?
  10. In approaching the Fiscal Committee’s report and Expenditure spreadsheet, two Basic Principles of Accounting come to mind, those of Full Disclosure and Conservatism. The Full Disclosure principle holds that all past, present and future information that may have had an impact on the financial performance needs to be fully disclosed. The Conservatism principle holds when choosing between two solutions, the one that will be least likely to overstate assets and income should be picked. My examination of the Fiscal Committee’s report and Expenditure spreadsheet suggests that neither of these tenets have been observed. My questions with regard to Full Disclosure are: 1) When will supporting documentation for all material line item savings be made available to the public? 2)Why was this documentation not made immediately available along with the Report and Expenditures spreadsheet so that ample time was available to the public to properly critique the Report? My question with regard to Conservatism is:  Will you endorse the idea of retaining a reputable Accounting Firm to ascertain the accuracy of your figures in regard to estimated savings obtained from consolidation, and to perform similar analysis on current year budgets and cost projections?

1.08.2013

FC emails: Revised Sheets for Tax Rates and Differences

From: yalescribe@att.net [mailto:yalescribe@att.net] 
Sent: Tuesday, January 08, 2013 6:12 PM
To: David Lent; IRA MARGOLIS; susan zimit; sally Rhoads; nancy branco
Subject: Re: REVISED SHEETS FOR TAX RATES AND DIFFERENCES

The only thing I catch is that the police district (and all districts in contemplation of our merger proposal) are "benefit assessment districts," not a "special" district -- which has a distinct meaning in the law of New York. -- Ross



From: David Lent <dslent30@msn.com>
To: IRA MARGOLIS <sabfinance@aol.com>; susan zimit <supervisorzimet@townofnewpaltz.org>; sally Rhoads <sallymrhoads@gmail.com>; nancy branco <nancybranco@villageofnewpaltz.org>; Ross Pollack <yalescribe@att.net>
Sent: Tue, January 8, 2013 3:02:02 PM
Subject: REVISED SHEETS FOR TAX RATES AND DIFFERENCES
TO ALL:  FOR THE LAST TIME THIS ARE THE FIGURES AND RATES .  i HAVE DOUBLED CHECKED AGAINST THE LAST SPREADSHEETS.  dAVE