To All; Since I have not received any objections the next mtg of the Committee will be held at 7:00 PM Tuesday December 18th in Susan Zimet's office. Attached are the charts I have developed based upon the last meeting and charts dated 12/10. I had to make some modifications to that data as we had not included the fire taxes raised by the town and paid to the Village. Also since the Town was late making their payment to th e village it looks like the Village got two town payments in the 2011 Village calendar. The Agenda for Tuesday A. Explanation of charts and letter by D. Lent
B. Distribution of other committee reports and discussion on their reports.
________________________________________ From: David Lent [mailto:dslent30@msn.com] Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 1:00 PM To: sally Rhoads; susan zimit; IRA MARGOLIS; Ross Pollack; nancy branco Subject: Analysis of Zone Reports
To All: I've been analyzing the 2009 Police Zone Reports . Data is Attached. As I expected there are two areas of very high activity. Downtown New Paltz ( Bounded Main St to the Bridge and on + property wide) and the area in the Town form the Village line to the thruway and on property wide. Also the data is highly impacted by extensive security checks. These seem to always be the same property. Town today and the community in the future should consider taking some action against high offenders. Will kept you up to date with additional analysis. Dave
00:03:40 Didn't make it to the Village Board meeting tonight but I listened to a bit of the 12/10 FC meeting where the committee reviews their final figures "to make sure everything ... is copasetic." At 4:07, Sally says
"... Nancy and I on Friday added complete footnotes, so that the explanation for what we did is there."
The brief single sentences in the Notes column of the Expenditures spreadsheet is supposed to be 'complete footnotes' and apparently adequate explanations. We know that Sally and Nancy have worked with professional-grade reports for years, so how could they possibly think that these brief phrases are 'complete' footnotes (aside from the fact that technically they aren't footnotes at all)?
00:05:40 Committee reviews the group of lines represented by A1340.1 Budget, A1325.1 Treasurer's Office, and A1430.1 Personnel/Payroll, which jointly show a savings of $68,935. Dave questions this, asking:
"that's sufficient to handle all of that operation?"Sally: "yep"Nancy: "yeah, it's just moving their bodies into this office..."Dave: "...all I'm questioning is, you know -- trying to be devil's advocate a little bit, okay -- we're talking about total savings of ... $67,000 between that combination..."
The exchange continues and Nancy suggests breaking out the contractual costs because that would explain help the difference, but Sally and Dave say no, that'll make it more confusing. [though actually it would help]. Nancy then says:
"because their actual salaries, per Susan, are covered in that $74,000"Dave: "okay"
Had they actually looked at the contractual expenses associated with those lines, they would have seen that all combined contractual doesn't COME CLOSE to adding up to $68,935 in savings -- in fact, it's only about $4,000 each for town and village. So what about the other $60,000? How many of those bookkeeper bodies are not being moved into the new office, but are actually going to be pink slipped?
Note about Dave Lent: In the videos I've watched, Dave often questions things, but he doesn't stay with it -- he ends up just consenting. I wish he had looked deeper when he thought the numbers didn't make sense, because his instincts were correct. His role in the FC committee was more facilitative -- that is, until the FC committee presented its findings when he unfortunately was willing to be front man for their sketchy work. In a different work group, without Susan and especially Sally driving hard for deep savings, I think Dave would have reached more sound conclusions.
01:55:00 Question: Can the sewer #6 situation be effectively and cost-efficiently solved in any other way than through consolidation? Perhaps there is significant cost savings with that aspect. This topic was discussed at the FC 12/3 meeting at 1h55m.
Sewer- $ 84,700.00 (will be paid off in 2013/2014 budget)
$320,000.00 (shared cost with Woodland Pond) sewer rehab project Henry W Dubois) village portion outstanding $160,000.00
Water-$1,765,000.00
Nancy
From: David Lent [mailto:dslent30@msn.com] Sent: Friday, December 07, 2012 10:27 AM To: Nancy Branco Subject: WATER AND SEWER RATE IMPACTS FROM CONSOLIDATION
Nancy, As I mentioned in my phone message I had an idea this morning as to how to address the impact of consolidating the water and sewer districts. Since the present cost to the town(outside of payments to Village) is only 5% of village costs and therefore minor impact, if I just change the percentage each area is responsible for and compare to what it is responsible for now and after consolidation and then determine the percentage change I got the info needed. Have done on the sheet I've attached. I assumed SUNY would continue to pay 150% rate. I assumed there is still outstanding debt on the Water Plant. PLease get back to me as soon as you can. I've also revised the final report and want to get to the committee as soon as possible so they can review and suggest changes. Dave
To All: Attached is my latest draft of a proposed final report. Ross - If you haven't done it yet you need to A2130 (Landfill revenues savings to 2K and change 2011 merge column and also expenditures line A90508 total proposed expenditures should reflect the $164,856 deducted. When change done send to the Committee.
I welcome your thoughts and changes, as long as they aren't to drastic.